Employee pay claim triage
An employee says they’ve been underpaid or a right was refused. Find out what the law says, the dates that matter, what to gather, and what not to do before you reply.
Figures checked 9 November 2026. Free to use, no sign-in.
See resultUnderpaid wages, penalties or overtime
Dates that matter
11 November 2026
Acknowledge the complaint
Not a legal deadline. A short written acknowledgement within a couple of days shows the complaint is being taken seriously.
Suggested · Good practice
23 November 2026
Full written response
Not a legal deadline. Two weeks is usually enough to check records and the award. Give the employee the date in your acknowledgement and keep to it.
Suggested · Good practice
9 November 2020
Six-year look-back starts
If the employee started proceedings on 9 November 2026, a court could not order back pay for any period before 9 November 2020. The date moves forward each day they wait. It limits what a court can order, not what was owed.
Time limit · FW Act s 545(5)
9 November 2019
Records you should still hold from
Time and wage records must be kept for 7 years, so records from 9 November 2019 onward should be on file.
Set by law · FW Act s 535(1)
What the law says
- Employees must be paid at least the award or agreement rate for their classification, with every penalty, loading, allowance and overtime rate that applies, in full and at least monthly. (FW Act s 45, s 50, s 323(1))
- An employee can recover unpaid amounts in court, including through the small claims procedure for up to $100,000, and the court must add interest if asked. (FW Act s 545, s 547, s 548(2))
- A court cannot order back pay for any period more than 6 years before the employee starts proceedings, and an application about a contravention must be made within 6 years of it. (FW Act s 544, s 545(5))
- Since 1 January 2025 it is a crime to intentionally fail to pay wages, super or other required amounts. Honest mistakes are not the offence, but a known underpayment left unpaid is hard to call unintentional. (FW Act s 327A)
- The offence does not cover super, long service leave or certain other leave pay if you are covered by the Fair Work Act only because your state referred its powers (generally sole traders, partnerships and other unincorporated employers in New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, South Australia and Tasmania). Civil claims for those amounts still apply. (FW Act s 327A(2))
Your position
Time and wage records kept (s 535)
MetUse them to check each point the employee raises, period by period.
Pay slips given within one working day (s 536)
MetPay slips show what was paid and at what rate. Keep copies with your response.
Small business: the Wage Compliance Code can apply
ConfirmIf the Fair Work Ombudsman is satisfied you complied with the Code, it cannot refer an underpayment for prosecution (s 327B(2)). The Code looks at how you responded when the employee raised it and how promptly you fixed it (Code s 6(3)(f), s 10, s 11(d)). Civil claims and back pay still apply.
Gather before you respond
- The award or enterprise agreement, the classification you used and why
- Rosters, timesheets and clock-in records for the period claimed
- The pay rates applied in each pay run, including penalties, overtime and allowances
- Pay slips for the period claimed (s 536)
- Time and wage records for the period claimed (s 535)
- The employment contract and any individual flexibility arrangement
How to respond
- Check each point in the complaint against your records and the award, one pay period at a time. A complaint drafted with an AI tool may cite the wrong award, clause or rate, and may also be right. Answer the substance, not the source.
- If you aren’t sure yet, acknowledge the complaint now, give a date for your full answer, and use the time to run the numbers or get advice.
- Keep a dated record of every step you take: when you received it, what you checked, the advice you got and when you paid. That record is your Code evidence.
What not to do
- Don’t cut shifts or hours, change their roster or duties, issue a warning, or dismiss them because they complained. That is adverse action, and you would have to prove the complaint wasn’t the reason (s 340, s 342, s 361).
- Don’t tell other staff about the complaint or treat the employee differently from others.
- Don’t ask the employee to accept less than the award, agreement or NES minimum, or to sign away their claim as a condition of being paid what is owed.
- Don’t create, alter or backdate records or pay slips. Knowingly false records are a separate contravention (s 535(4), s 536(3)).
- Don’t sit on a known underpayment while you argue about part of it. Pay what you agree is owed now and keep discussing the rest.
- Dates marked “Suggested” are good practice, not legal deadlines. Check any award or enterprise agreement that applies: it may add steps or a dispute procedure.
General information, not legal advice.
Take this further
Check the whole team, not just one person
The Workfloor team pay audit compares every employee’s hourly rate with the award minimum from one spreadsheet. The file is read in your browser.
Try it freeBy creating an account you agree to our Terms and Privacy policy.
Next step
Ask the Workfloor HR advisor
A tool gives you a figure or a draft; the advisor answers the question that comes next, with the section of the law or the award clause behind each answer. Your question is ready: change it to fit your business before you send it.
Starts with this question
An employee says I owe them money. How do I check whether they are right, which records should I look at, and how should I respond?
Free to try: 2 questions, no card. Nothing is sent until you press Ask.
By creating an account you agree to our Terms and Privacy policy.
How this works
Pick the type of complaint and answer a few questions. The checker sets out:
- the rules that apply, with the Fair Work Act sections;
- dates: the 6-year look-back for money claims, the 21-day flexible work response, dismissal claim windows, and suggested dates for your own reply;
- your position on records and pay slips, and whether the Small Business Wage Compliance Code can apply;
- what to gather, how to respond, and what to avoid.
Then reply with the claim response letter. For the numbers, use the underpayment exposure calculator, the award compliance audit or the super guarantee charge calculator, and record your good-faith steps with the Wage Compliance Code check. Nothing you type leaves your browser.
Legal basis
- Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 544 and s 545(5): 6-year time limits (opens external site)
- Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 535, s 536 and s 557C: records, pay slips and the burden of proof (opens external site)
- Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 327A and s 327B: wage theft offence and the Code (opens external site)
- Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 65A and s 65B: flexible working responses within 21 days (opens external site)
- Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 340, s 341(1)(c) and s 361: no adverse action for a complaint (opens external site)
- Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 62 and s 333M–333P: extra hours and the right to disconnect (opens external site)
- Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code Declaration 2024, s 6, s 10 and s 11 (opens external site)
Checked against these sources on 9 November 2026. Spotted a figure that looks wrong? Tell us.
Questions
How far back can an employee claim unpaid wages?
Up to 6 years. A court cannot order back pay for any period more than 6 years before the employee starts proceedings (Fair Work Act s 545(5)), and the 6 years runs back from the day they file, not the day they first complained. The limit restricts what a court can order. It doesn’t change what you owed at the time. For super, this is the Fair Work limit only: the ATO’s own time limits differ.
The complaint looks like it was written by an AI tool. Does that matter?
Not to whether it is right. Check each point against your records and the award. These complaints sometimes cite the wrong award, clause or section, and sometimes they are exactly right. Respond to the substance, politely and in writing.
Can an underpayment lead to criminal charges?
Since 1 January 2025 it is an offence to intentionally fail to pay wages or other required amounts (s 327A). Honest mistakes are not the offence. If you are covered by the Fair Work Act only because your state referred its powers (generally sole traders, partnerships and other unincorporated employers in New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, South Australia and Tasmania), the offence does not cover super, long service leave or certain other leave pay (s 327A(2)); civil claims for those still apply. If you have fewer than 15 employees and the Fair Work Ombudsman is satisfied you complied with the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code, it cannot refer the matter for prosecution (s 327B). The Code looks at how you responded once the employee raised it and how promptly you fixed it.
How long do I have to answer a flexible working request?
21 days from the request, in writing (s 65A(1)). If you refuse, or the 21 days pass without a written response, the employee can take the dispute to the Fair Work Commission after first trying to resolve it with you (s 65B).
Can I change the employee’s shifts while the complaint is being sorted out?
Be very careful. Cutting hours, changing the roster or duties, or a warning because someone complained is adverse action (s 340, s 342). If the employee says it was because of the complaint, you have to prove it wasn’t (s 361). Write down the real reason for any decision before you make it.